Americans less enchanted as sole superpower

“What we are seeing is a more sober assessment for the U.N. instead of the extremes of loving it or leaving it,” Feinstein said.

Elites even more downbeat
The quadrennial report is especially significant because it surveys two separate populations: Americans at large and a sample of what Pew calls “opinion leaders” — journalists, academics, state and local government officials, religious leaders and experts in foreign affairs, national security, science, engineering and the military. The results, which are reported separately, paint a vivid picture of an America deeply at odds with those whom it pays to do its thinking for it.

If anything, the “influentials” (the report’s shorthand for its sample of opinion leaders) are even gloomier about America’s world prospects than the public as a whole. For example, 37 percent of Americans as a whole believe the U.S. effort to establish a stable democracy in Iraq will fail, but that view is held by 84 percent of scientists, 71 percent of foreign affairs specialists and 63 percent of journalists.

Meanwhile, while 44 percent of Americans believe the war in Iraq has damaged the international struggle against terrorism, higher percentages in every opinion leader category hold that view — including military leaders and 82 percent of those who study foreign affairs for a living.

And, except for military leaders, all of the categories of “influentials” are more downbeat about prospects for democracy in the Middle East. Even then, only 34 percent of the public (and the same percentage of military leaders) believe it will ever happen; by comparison, only 17 percent of foreign affairs specialists and 14 percent of security experts agree.

Prospects for Republicans cloudy
Republicans suffered a poor showing in off-year elections this month, and with next year’s midterm races approaching, the survey suggests that candidates allied or identified with Bush could have a struggle on their hands. Overall, 51 percent of Americans in general disapprove of Bush’s handling of foreign affairs, and 57 percent disapprove specifically of his handling of Iraq.

“You don’t get a second chance to make a first impression on Iraq,” Feinstein said. “Once the public sours on a war, they don’t unsour, and the consequences for the president’s foreign policy are that the revolution is over.”

All categories surveyed agreed that the U.S. image abroad has declined since 9/11 — including half of Republicans. The reasons for this, however, are another indicator of the divide between the nation as a whole and its opinion leaders. All categories agree that the war in Iraq is a major factor, but the general public largely dismisses U.S. support for Israel as a reason (a factor cited by 39 percent), while large majorities of most of the “influentials” — 78 percent of journalists and 72 percent of both military leaders and security experts — cited it as significant.

For the general survey, Princeton Survey Research Associates International questioned 2,006 adults by telephone. It reported a margin of sampling error of plus or minus 2.5 percentage points.

For the survey of “influentials,” Pew and the Council on Foreign Relations questioned 520 opinion leaders in eight fields: news media; foreign relations; security; state and local government; colleges, universities and think tanks; religious organizations; science and engineering; and the military. Respondents were interviewed by telephone and through a screened, invitation-only Web site. The survey did not report a margin of error.

MORE FROM POLITICS

Politics Section Front

Ethics report: Palin abused authority Anti-Obama anger erupts at McCain events Leading in polls, Obama plays it safe Newsweek poll: Obama opens double-digit lead N.Y. mixup: 'Barack Osama' on ballot Parties wage war over voter fraud, intimidation Newsweek: Will there be a 'reverse Bradley effect'? Obama: McCain trying to divide country Brownstein: The risk of McCain's health plan McCain, Obama offer ideas to aid economy Politics Section Front   Add Politics headlines to your news reader: