A glimpse inside the supersecret world of intel

WASHINGTON - Who knows how many times West Virginia's Sen. Jay Rockefeller, the Democratic vice chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, has sat on his hands or held his tongue about how our country gathers intelligence in the war on terror. But on Saturday, when President Bush acknowledged a highly classified domestic spying program, Rockefeller was liberated and spoke out against it.

Together, Rockefeller and Bush have pulled back the curtain on the supersecret world of the intelligence gathering and congressional oversight. What's been discovered, Senate Democrats and some Republicans say, is too much gathering with too little oversight.

The New York Times broke the story on Friday about the National Security Agency program of domestic wiretapping. The next day the president “outed” the program, saying he had the authority to do it and that “leaders in Congress have been briefed more than a dozen times on this authorization and the activities conducted under it.”

Membership has its privileges
As a member of the so-called “gang of four” which includes the top Republican and Democrat of the Senate and House intelligence committees, Rockefeller was one of four members of Congress who received those briefings. The group can be summoned to the White House on short notice to be advised on the most sensitive intelligence information or plans for covert operations. It is safe to assume that if the United States is, in fact, operating secret prisons overseas, these four know plenty about them.

MSNBC TV VIDEO Bush forceful on spying Dec. 19: President Bush says he will continue the domestic surveillance. MSNBC

But membership also has its burdens. The "gang" — Republican Sen. Pat Roberts of Kansas and Rep. Peter Hoekstra of Michigan and Democrats Rockefeller and Rep. Jane Harman of California — is virtually gagged from discussing anything from meetings with anyone outside the group — not even other senators, staffers or lawyers with security clearance on the intelligence committees. “You can't discuss it with anybody as long as you live,” Rockefeller said Monday.

And for Rockefeller and Harmon, the senior Democrats on the Senate and House intelligence committees, respectively, membership can be even more problematic. If they want to object to anything the administration is doing, they're forbidden from doing so publicly.

That was the case with Rockefeller until Monday. He'd informed the administration he had concerns and was suspicious of the NSA program, but he had no recourse to stop it from going forward and he couldn't go public. “I wasn't going to say anything until the president starting talking about it so openly,” he said.

‘They implied implicit consent’
In laying out his case for the NSA's domestic wire tapping on Saturday, Bush told the nation, “Leaders in Congress have been briefed more than a dozen times on this authorization and the activities conducted under it.” Questioned about whether executive power had run amok at Monday’s presidential news conference, an irritated Bush replied, “We're talking to Congress all the time, and on this program, to suggest there's unchecked power is not listening to what I'm telling you. I'm telling you, we have briefed the United States Congress on this program a dozen times.”

Rockefeller was annoyed. “They're just saying we're all briefed and informed and they implied implicit consent and all the rest of that and it's totally untrue,” he recounted outside the Senate chamber after Bush's news conference. He said the impression the administration was leaving was “totally phony.”

But once the president acknowledged — and defended — the classified program, it became unclassified. Rockefeller was then able to go back to a secure space in the Senate Intelligence Committee's offices and retrieve a handwritten letter he'd given to the Vice President Dick Cheney more than two years ago.

“I am retaining a copy of this letter in a sealed envelope,” the letter said, “to ensure that I have a record of this communication.”

MORE FROM SECURITY

Security Section Front

Israel introduces step-on scanner FBI releases files on Jack Anderson Report: NSA spied on soldiers' personal calls Court blocks order to free Gitmo detainees No credible intel predicting terrror attack Documents say U.S. detainee near insanity Security Section Front   Add Security headlines to your news reader: